Advertisment
drgreene.com Home
Dec 04

Not All Hand Sanitizers Are the Same

One of the best ways to keep your toddlers healthy during flu and cold season is to keep their hands clean. A good washing with soap and water is very effective in reducing the spread of contaminants that may make your kids sick. But frankly it can be tough to get our little ones to wash up, and even tougher to get them to scrub thoroughly and often enough to do get the job done – especially when you’re out and about. Hand sanitizers, recommended by the Centers for Disease Control, are both a time-saver and hassle-reducer for busy parents. With a little squirt of gel, about 99.9 percent of the germs that cause illness can be history – even the H1N1 virus. These are a great advance for keeping families healthy.

Not all hand sanitizers are the same. Some depend on ethyl alcohol, some on the quaternary ammonia chemical benzalkonium chloride (sometimes labeled “Alcohol Free!” to imply that it’s safer), and some on Thymol, a safe, plant-based ingredient that gets the job done. Of the three types, I prefer Thymol for thumb-sucking toddlers, although I’m not opposed to using alcohol-based sanitizers on young children if that’s what’s available.

If you’re using any hand sanitizers on your little ones, I suggest you supervise. Rub the gel in thoroughly and keep your child in sight until it dries. Evaporation is your friend. If your child’s thumb starts moving towards the mouth immediately after application, don’t panic, but do try to distract him for a few minutes if you can.

For effective hand washing, I teach kids to sing “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star” or “The Alphabet Song” while washing to remind them to scrub long enough and hard enough to make a difference. Besides washing before meals, the most important times to wash are after sneezing or coughing, after using the toilet, upon leaving “high-risk” places such as doctors’ offices, daycare centers, playgrounds, etc, and always upon arriving home.


Originally posted December 4, 2009

3 Responses to Not All Hand Sanitizers Are the Same

  1. Ben
    | December 6th, 2009 at 10:05 pm

    Recently, I have heard some hubbub about hand sanitizer and a negative health effect. I think the just of the various reports was that we need some bio-critters on us and the anti-bacterial gets rid of the good ones as well as the bad ones. Is there any truth to this?

  2. Dr. Larry Rosen
    | December 7th, 2009 at 6:51 am

    There are less toxic alternatives that parents/teachers can make for their homes and schools. I’ve written about the “thieves” blend using essential oils at http://www.thewholechild.us/integrative_/2009/09/the-secret-of-thieves.html

    Dr. Larry Rosen, Founder of the Whole Child Center

  3. Charlie
    | December 14th, 2009 at 11:07 am

    Thanks so much for this! I get very concerned about keeping green while still making sure my daughter is protected against H1N1. There is a great report here from the Environmental Working Group about disinfection in schools and H1N1, and it rates different solutions for how green and non-toxic they are: http://bit.ly/EWGGreenSchools

Leave a Reply

We invite and welcome your comments. Please contribute to a polite and sincere discussion. Constructive disagreement is always fine, but personal attacks and disruptive comments are never acceptable, neither to the poster of the article nor to other readers who offer their comments. Any comment that seems designed to offend, or to disrupt a conversation rather than contribute to it, or is simply a commercial message, will be summarily deleted. Thank you for helping us keep the discussion going!